Is Labor pushing for new harsh anti-refugee laws?

July 14, 2025
Issue 
Refugees and their supporters protesting for permanent visas outside Tony Burke's office, March 9. Photo: Zebedee Parkes

Tony Burke, home affairs and immigration and citizenship minister, is again 聽that the 2023 landmark High Court ruling has limited his ability to lock up migrants and refugees.

That case ruled that the indefinite immigration detention 鈥 Labor鈥檚 idea 鈥 was 鈥渦nlawful and unconstitutional鈥. Further, it said people who could not forcibly be returned to their home countries could no longer be detained. Those who had been convicted of a crime and had served their sentence had to be released.

Importantly, it said indefinite immigration detention constitutes punishment.

This ruling upset the major parties鈥 racist policies so they rushed through last November making it legal to forcibly remove asylum seekers to third countries while giving themselves immunity from being sued by those deportees who were harmed.

Labor expanded its power to revisit protection findings, meaning that even those deemed to be refugees could still be returned to their home country. It can also now impose harsh visa conditions on people who stay.

Now Burke says the to imprison someone are 鈥渕ore difficult to reach鈥 and, as a result, community safety is 鈥渦nder threat鈥.

He has cited the case of a man who was released, under a court鈥檚 direction, who has subsequently attacked someone else, leading him to die.

Coalition spokesperson Andrew Hastie has seized on the opportunity to push Burke to enact new laws. Now both parties want to make it easier to deport people they describe as 鈥渄angerous鈥. If they cannot do that, Hastie said, new laws are required. This is despite the fact that any attacker, if convicted, is likely to go to jail.

Despite politicians鈥 and corporate media lies, the majority of refugees held in detention have never committed violent crimes. The handful who have served their time before being released.

Locking up of refugees, particularly those who arrive by boat, helps justify the major parties鈥 systematic vilification of refugees for the legal act of seeking asylum.

The bipartisan demonisation of refugees, under the guise of 鈥減rotecting the community鈥, is nothing new: Labor鈥檚 1992 policy of mandatory detention was couched in this rhetoric.

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese promised, before Labor was elected in 2022, to give permanent visas to 19,000 refugees on temporary protection visas and safe haven enterprise visas. Thousands more are still on bridging, or expired, visas.

But after three years, little has been done to address the plight of tens of thousands of people living in limbo for more than 11 years, because their claims were not properly assessed under the misnamed 鈥淔ast Track鈥 process.

Frances Rush,聽from the聽, Labor鈥檚 refusal to help these people as 鈥渋ntentionally cruel and callous鈥. This聽聽affects every part of a refugee鈥檚 life, including their聽ability to find work, start study, access to services and recover from trauma.

Labor has spent more funds on criminalising refugees than resettling them. According to the聽, the vast majority of funds that relate to refugees is spent on preventing people from seeking asylum in Australia.

While is being spent on the cruel immigration detention system, Australia has cut funding to the聽United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees,聽making it near impossible for refugees from Gaza to seek safety in Australia even as Israel continues its genocide.

Labor has also broken its promise to raise its humanitarian intake to a measly 27,000 people, which has聽remained at 20,000 places. This rich country has the capacity to take many more refugees, and could easily provide an additional intake for Palestinian refugees.

No help has been sent to help refugees聽and people seeking asylum in Papua New Guinea, one of the government鈥檚 鈥渢hird countries鈥 for people it deports.

Labor has also abandoned its responsibilities to 12,000 Hazara refugees stuck in聽Indonesia, which is not a signatory to the 1951 United Nations Refugee Convention and therefore does not offer protection.

Hundreds of desperate refugees across Indonesia protested ahead of Anthony Albanese鈥檚 visit in May, to demand urgent action on their resettlement cases. Some have been waiting for more than 10 years to be reunited with families.

Now, as United States President Donald Trump聽聽migrants in cages on a prison camp before trying to deport them it should not be forgotten that he said he 鈥渁dmired鈥 Australia鈥檚 offshore detention system.

Refugees, who arrived in Australia by boat a decade ago, and expected to resettle in the United States, are now being affected by Trump鈥檚 freeze on聽.

A majority saw through the Coalition鈥檚 fear聽campaign and rejected Trump-like politics at the election. But Burke is not prepared to be outflanked by Hastie; after 聽a 61-year-old Palestinian woman鈥檚 visa, he now seems to be gearing up to introduce new punitive anti-refugee laws.

As we prepare to mark 12 years since former Labor PM Kevin Rudd announced the 鈥淧apua New Guinea solution鈥, on July 19, declaring that people who seek asylum by boat will never be settled here, all supporters of justice need to step up efforts to stop Labor鈥檚 cruelty.

For its part, Socialist Alliance will continue to call for an end to mandatory detention, here and in Nauru, for refugees in聽Indonesia to be bought to Australia and for permanent visas for those still in limbo.

[Chloe DS is a member of the 聽National Executive.]聽

You need 91自拍论坛, and we need you!

91自拍论坛 is funded by contributions from readers and supporters. Help us reach our funding target.

Make a One-off Donation or choose from one of our Monthly Donation options.

Become a supporter to get the digital edition for $5 per month or the print edition for $10 per month. One-time payment options are available.

You can also call 1800 634 206 to make a donation or to become a supporter. Thank you.